NASA
has decided to effectively srap the Hubble Space Telescope by canceling
a servicing mission when the Shuttle becomes operational again.
(See the NASA white paper defending this
decision.)
The
Mars Society joins many scientists, astronauts, and other space
groups who are trying to save the Hubble. (See the Save
the Hubble Web site.)
Here
is a recent "Hubble Letter" from the Mars Society Web
site:
In a letter to Senator Barbara Mikulski (D-MD) made
public today, Admiral Hal Gehman, the chairman of the Columbia Accident
Investigation Board (CAIB), called for a review of NASA Administrator
Sean O'Keefe's decision to abandon the Hubble Space Telescope.
Administrator O'Keefe has claimed that Hubble missions are too
dangerous to fly, and that that the recommendations of Gehman's
CAIB forbid any Shuttle mission to Hubble. In a forceful rebuff
to Mr. O'Keefe, Gehman explicitly denied both of these claims.
With respect to Mr. O'Keefe's claim that Hubble missions were substantially
more dangerous than ISS missions, Gehman said: "Almost all
the risk is concentrated in the front and back of the mission, where
one goes on orbit makes little difference."
Gehman added that while ISS missions offer a "small"
risk reduction relative to dealing with debris shredding events,
"There are many other factors that influence the total risk
equation, sometimes very significantly. One of the more significant
factors is the heavy cargo loads that are frequently carried to
ISS at high inclinations, which create risk factors of their own."
Gehman's citing of the greater ISS flight risk due to heavy loads
and high inclination orbits (== freezing water North Atlantic launch
aborts) is very welcome. These issues were first brought to widespread
public attention by Mars Society President Dr. Robert Zubrin several
widely circulated articles.
With respect to rejecting Mr. O'Keefe's claim that Gehman's CAIB
report forbids a Hubble upgrade mission, Gehman was equally blunt,
saying the CAIB report should be read as saying "Do the best
you can." He added; "The CAIB allowed more latitude in
complying with our recommendations for non-ISS missions, which may
be slightly more risky, taking into account only the debris shredding
threat to the Orbiter."
Gehman concluded, "only a deep and rich study of the entire
gain/risk equation can answer the question of whether an extension
of the life of the wonderful Hubble telescope is worth the risks
involved."
Gehman's letter provides critical ammunition to those fighting
to save Hubble. In a statement issued after the Gehman letter was
made public, Representative Mark Udall (D-CO) the author of bipartisan
congressional resolution to save Hubble (H Resolution 550) said;
"I am pleased that Admiral Gehman agrees with Sen. Mikulski
and those of us who have sponsored H. Res 550 that 'a deep and rich
study of the entire gain/risk equation' is needed to determine the
best course forward in servicing the Hubble space Telescope
.I
strongly believe that NASA Administrator O'Keefe should ask an independent
panel, such as one organized by the National Research Council to
[provide such a deep and rich study]. Only through such an independent
review will it be possible to assess all our options for safely
servicing Hubble."
"I am not prepared to accept such an arbitrary cancellation
of the planned servicing mission to the Hubble in the absence of
an independent review. Just yesterday, we had yet another reminder
of the ways Hubble continues to rewrite the astronomy textbooks
and fundamentally alter our worldview. We should do all that we
can in a responsible fashion to ensure that this capability is not
lost prematurely."
Udall's save Hubble bill now has 23 cosponsors. With O'Keefe's
primary claims used to justify Hubble desertion now discredited,
it should be possible to rapidly get more. Call your congressman
today through the congressional switchboard at 202-224-3121. Ask
to speak to his or her Legislative Assistant in charge of space
policy, and then explain to that person that the congressman should
become a cosponsor of H. Res 550.
For Hubble, for science, for the pioneer spirit, and for Mars:
Was there ever a nobler cause? Call today. 202-224-3121.